Re: 3way Ends & Means

Brendan Kennelly (worcgst3@kub.nl)
Wed, 22 Jul 1998 15:19:31 MET

Regarding Stuart White's distinction between soft and hard
corporatism I am skeptical whether the Dutch experience could be
easily adapted to Britain. I think it is important to remember that
long before the Waasenaar Accord of 1982, there was a strong
tradition of a consensus approach to social and economic policy in
the Netherlands (based on the pillarisation model). I doubt whether
the loose wage agreemnts in the Netherlands could work in a country
like Britain which has a long tradition of more antagonistic
capital-labour relations.

Ireland has tried both soft and hard corporatism in the last 25
years. In the first experiment which lasted for about 10 years until
the early 1980s there is little evidence of success. Since 1987
more comprehensive type of social partnership agreements covering
specific increases for wages as well as tax and public expenditure
policies have been a critical factor in the irish economy in the last
ten years (see the article by Rory O'Donnell and Colm O'Reardon in
the New Economy in 1996).

I also think it is worth noting that successful corporatist
agreements were introduced in both Ireland and the Netherlands at
times of major economic crises. A momentum has developed in both
countries since their introduction which makes it much more difficult
for a reversion to free collective bargaining.

Brendan Kennelly

WORC,
Tilburg University
The Netherlands
-------------------------------------------------------------
Posted to 3way, a service of Nexus. http://www.netnexus.org/
Hosting and email provided by new media consultants On-Line Publishing